Hispanic Farm Workers Lax in Buckling Up, Using Child Seats
Hispanic farm workers believe they are good, safe and
informed drivers, yet many fail to use seat belts and rarely provide their young
child passengers with car seats, according to a new UC Davis
study. The study, part of an overall campus outreach and
research program to aid Spanish-speaking, low-literacy farm workers who work and
drive in California, will be published this month in the journal Accident
Analysis and Prevention. UC Davis researchers say they believe it is the first
such study to look at California farm workers' driving and car safety attitudes
and habits. The findings show clear and specific evidence of a
serious gap between "saying and doing," say Martha
Stiles, research associate, and James
Grieshop, a Cooperative Extension specialist, in the campus's human and
community development department. "Given the record of the Hispanic driving population
in California and the Central Valley, where these studies were conducted, it is
clear that the existence of this gap must be taken very seriously," Stiles and
Grieshop say in the paper. To overcome the gap between saying and doing, the
researchers suggest three elements: driver education materials that are
culturally sensitive; easy access to child car seats; and acceptable,
comprehensible training strategies. Law enforcement agencies, Hispanic community groups
and public health agencies must work together to design and distribute child
safety seats to these workers and their families, the authors say. "The creative
and effective use of these elements . . . can and will influence the positive
outcomes of any driver-safety program targeted to the large farm worker
population," the researchers say. Otherwise, "the gap between 'saying and doing'
will persist." The researchers conducted the study both through
face-to-face interviews in Spanish with farm workers and through surveys of
vehicles observed returning home to labor camps at the end of the work
day. Most surprising of all the findings, Stiles says, is
the non-use of restraints for children and adults. "I expected to find a reduced
use for adults, but not as low as what we found. This shows a specific need for
a specific group of people." Upon embarking on the study, the researchers found
California Highway Patrol statistics (1995) show that while Hispanics comprise
30 percent of the population in California's Central Valley, approximately 45
percent of crashes and 60 percent of DUI arrests involve Hispanic drivers and
passengers. In detail, the UC Davis researchers found in their
survey of 167 farmworkers that: -- The majority of those interviewed said they wore
safety belts consistently. Yet when observed returning from work, only 37
percent of vehicle occupants were using seat belts, compared with 68 percent of
vehicle occupants in the general public, according to a NHTSA
survey. -- While most of the households studied had children,
and 42 percent of the households had children under 4 years old, researcher
observations showed that regardless of the number of children under 40 pounds
and/or 4 or younger, only one car seat was available in each car. "In 66 percent
of the cases where a single child was carried, no car seat was used. In
two-thirds of the situations where two children were carried, no car seats were
seen," the researchers report. Yet, when interviewed, 75 percent of those with
children said they used child-safety seats. Reasons why safety belts or car seats weren't being
used reflect a lack of knowledge or understanding of the risks involved with not
utilizing the safety devices, Stiles and Grieshop say. "Much of the resistance
to using the safety devices is ingrained in basic behaviors and beliefs. These
workers and their families believe that drivers are safer on rural roads than
elsewhere. Because of the reduced traffic pressures, drivers also tend to relax
their safety skills," the researchers say. Yet, in fact just the opposite is true: Californians
traveling on rural roads in the Central Valley are three times more likely to be
involved in a fatal crash than on urban thoroughfares, the researchers
say. "Special efforts must be made to increase awareness
not only of the risk to themselves but those who ride with them," the
researchers say. "Cultural considerations are important in designing an approach
for this group." The study was funded by the National Highway Traffic
Safety Administration and the California Office of Traffic
Safety. As part of the overall project, the researchers
oversaw the development a few years ago of an educational driver safety game --
La Loteria del Manejo Seguro -- modeled after a popular Mexican game.
The game includes 54 brightly colored cards depicting traffic signs and safe
driving behavior. In addition, the researchers have begun a program of safe
driving training held at farm sites, labor centers, and traffic violators
schools, among other locations.